Amber Guyger

A former Dallas police officer was convicted of murder Tuesday in the fatal shooting of her unarmed neighbor who she said she believed was an intruder in her home.

The same jury that found Amber Guyger guilty in the September 2018 death of her upstairs neighbor, Botham Jean, sentenced her to 10 years in prison on Wednesday.

Several readers shared their thoughts on the Times-Review Facebook page.

Sheree Smith said she believes Guyger’s actions were a grave mistake.

“Unfortunately the mistake took an innocent life,” she said. “I pray that the family can forgive her and that she can forgive herself.”

Melissa Hutchison said Guyger deserves to go to prison.

“Her story always sounded fishy,” she said. “I have been intoxicated before and I always knew where my home was. She knew that was not her apartment. 

“I am sorry to say this, but I think she was a racist and this murder was racially motivated. I do not understand how she ever passed the psychological portion of Police entrance because she has a lot of factors that make a serial killer.”

Aaron Snyder said he believes Guyger deserves the death penalty. 

“It would have made a statement,” he said. “She rendered no aid. She deleted text messages. She was more concerned about covering up things. She showed no remorse. 

“She is equipped with a taser and pepper spray and probably mace as well. She could have handled it without lethal force. Police officers are trained to handle things with out using lethal force unless it’s life or death. She should be sentenced to death or life without parole and never be allowed out and die in prison.”

The jury took a matter of hours to convict Guyger, 31, after a six-day trial.

Cheers erupted in the courthouse as the verdict was announced, and someone yelled “Thank you, Jesus!” In the hallway outside the courtroom, a crowd celebrated and chanted “black lives matter.” When the prosecutors walked into the hall, they broke into cheers.

After the verdict was read, Guyger sat alone, weeping, at the defense table.

Family members are expected to testify about how they were affected by the killing of Jean, an accountant from the Caribbean island nation of St. Lucia. Guyger’s defense attorneys can argue that she deserves a light sentence because she acted out of sudden fear and confusion. The judge is expected to provide guidance on sentencing law. It is unclear how long the punishment phase of the trial will last.

The basic facts of the unusual shooting were not in dispute throughout the trial. After a long shift at work and still in uniform, Guyger walked up to Jean’s apartment — which was on the fourth floor, directly above hers on the third — and found the door unlocked. Thinking the apartment was her own, she drew her service weapon and entered.

Jean had been eating a bowl of ice cream when Guyger entered his home and shot him.

The shooting drew widespread attention because of the strange circumstances and because it was one in a string of shootings of unarmed black men by white police officers.

“A 26-year-old college-educated black man, certified public accountant, working for one of the big three accounting firms in the world ... it shouldn’t take all of that for unarmed black and brown people in America to get justice,” Benjamin Crump, one of the lawyers for Jean’s family, said at a news conference Tuesday.

Crump said the verdict honors other people of color who were killed by police officers who were not convicted of a crime.

Attorney Lee Merritt, who also represents the family, underlined Crump’s words.

“This is a huge victory, not only for the family of Botham Jean, but this is a victory for black people in America. It’s a signal that the tide is going to change here. Police officers are going to be held accountable for their actions, and we believe that will begin to change policing culture around the world,” Merritt said.

The jury that convicted Guyger was largely made up of women and people of color.

The verdict also defused tensions that began simmering Monday when jurors were told they could consider whether Guyger had a right to use deadly force under a Texas law known as the castle doctrine — even though she wasn’t in her own home.

The law is similar to “stand your ground” measures across the U.S. that state a person has no duty to retreat from an intruder. Prosecutor Jason Fine told jurors that while the law would have empowered Jean to shoot someone barging into his apartment, it doesn’t apply “the other way around.”

Guyger was arrested three days after the killing. She was later fired and charged with murder . Tension has been high during the trial in Dallas, where five police officers were killed in an attack three years ago.

Guyger tearfully apologized for killing Jean and told the jurors she feared for her life upon finding the door to what she thought was her apartment unlocked. Guyger said Jean approached her when she entered the unit with her gun out. Prosecutors suggested he was just rising from a couch toward the back of the room when the officer shot him.

In a frantic 911 call played repeatedly during the trial, Guyger said “I thought it was my apartment” nearly 20 times. Her lawyers argued that the identical physical appearance of the apartment complex from floor to floor frequently led to tenants going to the wrong apartments.

But prosecutors questioned how Guyger could have missed numerous signs that she was in the wrong place, asked why she didn’t call for backup and suggested she was distracted by sexually explicit phone messages with her police partner.


Information in this report came from the Associated Press.

React to this story:


Recommended for you